Premise:
My name is Kvothe.
I have stolen princesses back from sleeping barrow kings. I burned down the town of Trebon. I have spent the night with Felurian and left with both my sanity and my life. I was expelled from the University at a younger age than most people are allowed in. I tread paths by moonlight that others fear to speak of during the day. I have talked to gods, loved women, and written songs that make the minstrels weep.
You may have heard of me.
I know, I usually write my own premise blurb, I just really loved this bit. It captures the feel of the story so well, even though most of that stuff doesn’t actually happen in the first volume. (Does that count as a spoiler? I don’t care about them so I usually don’t even notice spoilery bits in reviews.)
Thoughts:
I’ll go ahead and say I bought this because of the acclaim. It seems like everyone and their aunt was giddy with glee the day the release date for the long-awaited sequel was announced, so I picked it up, not really expecting much. Cynical? Maybe, but I’ve learned the hard way that popular doesn’t always equal good, especially not when you entertain a highly subjective and personal view of what good is. The first few chapters didn’t seem to bear much promise, either. It took fifty-two pages for the story to kick in properly. Though the information provided in those pages proved necessary for the plot as a whole, it was a little dry and drawn out.
But then Kvothe started talking (Yes, it’s first person and I usually hate it and all that blah blah blah) and I was immediately enthralled. This is just the sort of book I look for when I’m book-shopping: richly detailed, beautifully written, intricately plotted and a page count you can sink your teeth into. (722!)
This is storytelling at its finest. Despite the abundance of detail, the story never dragged much at all after the initial ‘meh’ of the beginning. I’m so glad I didn’t stop after the first chapter. I had considered it quite seriously; it took me longer to pick up the book again after that than it did for me to finish the rest of the book. I could not put it down.
Rating: Ripping Good Yarn
Not quite sparkling, but so close! If it had a few more female characters, I’d probably bump it up to my top rating, even with that clunky opening, but that’s really all it’s lacking. I’m not waiting for the paperback on the sequel, either. Since I’m such a cheapskate, with my Half Price Books addiction and all, that should tell you something in itself.
Influences:
There’s so much here to admire: the dialogue; the rich, flowing prose; the lush detail; worldbuilding both subtle and concise; Rothfuss’s ability to render an entirely sympathetic character of this flawed and scarred man. I wish I could have been more eloquent about all the things I liked, but it’s been a few weeks. None of my catch-up reviews are going to be very detailed, I’m afraid; all the information has been dumped to make room for the impending revisions for my rough draft. Yes, I finished it! Not that anyone I haven’t already told is going to read this, but I just had to throw it in somewhere. I can’t believe I posted two reviews without saying anything about it already…
Next up will be Changeless, by Gail Carriger. Moar braincandy for everyone!